Ataturk, Part II

Ataturk, Part II

At the close of World War I, it was left to Mustafa Kemal (later

to be called Ataturk) to save the remnants of the Ottoman Empire

from partition. The Allies exacted the harshest penalties of the

post-war era in the formulation of the Treaty of Sevres, which

attempted to dismember an Empire that had stretched through

much of the Middle East, with Britain, France, Italy and Greece

each coveting a chunk. France was granted Syria by a mandate

from the League of Nations. Britain, also under League

mandate, received Iraq and Palestine, as well as Saudi Arabia

under a protectorate arrangement. Italy occupied Turkish

territory even as the peace conference was proceeding, and

Greek forces moved into Smyrna and Thrace (modern-day

western Turkey).

Mustafa Kemal, the only Ottoman hero to emerge from the Great

War, was upset that the man he helped put into power in the

1913 coup, Enver Pasha, was capitulating to the Allies. In 1917

Mustafa had made the following observation about the rule of the

man he once greatly admired.

“There are no bonds left between the Government and the

people. What we call the people are composed now of women,

disabled men, and children. For all alike the Government is the

power which insistently drives them to hunger and death. The

administrative machinery is devoid of authority. Public life is in

full anarchy. Every new step taken by the Government increases

the general hatred the people feel for it. All officials accept

bribes, and are capable of every sort of corruption and abuse.

The machinery of justice has entirely stopped. The police forces

do not function. Economic life is breaking down with

formidable speed. Neither people nor government employees

have any confidence in the future. The determination to live rids

even the best and the most honest of every sort of sacred feeling.

If the War lasts much longer, the whole structure of Government

and dynasty, decrepit in all its parts, may suddenly fall to

pieces.” [Glenny] It did.

After Sevres, the nationalists coalesced around Kemal,

establishing their capital in Ankara, a small, undeveloped town

of some 20,000. [Today it is the capital of Turkey and has a

population of 2.6 million.] Then in September 1920, with the

Greeks occupying Smyrna, a very strange thing happened.

Greek leader Eleftherios Venizelos decided to hold elections in

November in order to take advantage of what he saw as the surge

in Greek nationalism because of the territorial rewards they had

gained through Sevres.

On September 30, Greek King Alexander was strolling the

palace gardens with his wolfhound, Fritz, when suddenly the dog

jumped into a clump of bushes. Hearing barks and the sounds of

a scuffle, Alexander checked it out and found Fritz shaking a pet

Spanish monkey in his teeth. While he was trying to free the

monkey from Fritz”s grip, another monkey (evidently the mate)

severely bit the King on the calf. While the wound was treated

and all appeared to be fine, just two days later fever set in and for

the next three weeks Alexander was in the fight of his life. He

lost it, October 25. Winston Churchill wrote of the incident, “It

is perhaps no exaggeration to remark that a quarter of a million

persons died of this monkey”s bite.”

The problem was that King Alexander”s death opened the issue

of succession right before the elections. It”s a complicated story

involving the royals, but Venizelos”s party was crushed at the

ballot box, clearing the way for the exiled King Constantine”s

return, much to the displeasure of the Allies who thought he had

collaborated with the Germans during the war. Venizelos was

then forced out of office and a new set of generals replaced the

existing military leadership, at exactly the worst possible time,

because Mustafa Kemal was preparing his forces to take back

what Turkey had lost at Sevres. Churchill commented, “At last

peace with Turkey: and to ratify it, War with Turkey!”

In March 1921, the Allies made a last attempt to avert war

between the two. Failing in these efforts, Greece attacked

Mustafa”s forces. Churchill later wrote:

“Loaded with follies, stained with crimes, rotted with

misgovernment, shattered by battle, worn down by long

disastrous wars, his Empire falling to pieces around him, the

Turk was still alive. In his breast was beating the heart of a race

that had challenged the world, and for centuries had contended

victoriously against all comers. In his hands was once again the

equipment of a modern army, and at his head a Captain, who

with all that is learned of him, ranks with the four or five great

figures of the cataclysm. In the tapestried and gilded chambers

of Paris were assembled the law-givers of the world. In

Constantinople, under the guns of the Allied Fleets there

functioned a puppet Government of Turkey. But among the stern

hills and valleys of ”the Turkish homeland” in Anatolia, there

dwelt that company of poor men…who would not see it settled

so; and at their bivouac fires at this moment sat in the rags of a

refugee the august Spirit of Fair Play.” [Kinzer]

The battle to retake western Turkey did not go well for Mustafa

Kemal at first, but by the summer of 1922, the military gains

were startling. The Greeks were pushed into the Aegean and the

French and Italians, guarding the Mediterranean, fled too.

Kemal”s stunning military success is described as one of the

great campaigns of modern history. In the words of author

Stephen Kinzer, “(Mustafa) had turned utter defeat into brilliant

triumph, ripping to shreds the Sevres treaty under which modern

Turkey was to have been aborted before it could be born.”

Now Kemal was set to consolidate his gains. On October 30,

1922, he arranged for a motion to be put forward in the national

assembly, one which would abolish, once and for all, the

Ottoman Empire and the Sultanate. Mustafa was rebuked, at

which point he proclaimed to the assembly:

“Gentlemen, neither the sovereignty nor the right to govern can

be transferred by one person to anybody else by an academic

debate. Sovereignty is acquired by force, by power and by

violence. It was by violence that the sons of Osman acquired the

power to rule over the Turkish nation and to maintain their rule

for more than six centuries. It is now the nation that revolts

against these usurpers, puts them in their right place and actually

carries on their sovereignty. This is an actual fact. It is no

longer a question of knowing whether we want to leave this

sovereignty in the hands of the nation or not. It is simply a

question of stating an actuality, something which is already an

accomplished fact and which must be accepted unconditionally

as such. And this must be done at any price. If those who are

assembled here, the Assembly and everybody else, would find

this quite natural, it would be very appropriate from my point of

view. Conversely, the reality will nevertheless be manifested in

the necessary form, but in that event it is possible that some

heads will be cut off.” [Macfie]

Weeks later the Sultan fled and within months the Republic of

Turkey was formally created. Next week, Mustafa Kemal

becomes…Ataturk.

Sources:

“The Balkans,” Misha Glenny

“Crescent & Star,” Stephen Kinzer

“Ataturk,” A.L. Macfie

“A History of Modern Europe,” John Merriman

“Europe: A History,” Norman Davies

“Twentieth Century,” J.M. Roberts

“The Middle East,” Bernard Lewis

Brian Trumbore