1919

1919

Pittsburgh Steelers Quiz: 1) Most rushing yards, season?

2) Most passing yards, season? 3) Most pass receptions, career?

4) How many seasons did Chuck Noll coach? Answers below.

The Black Sox

[Editor Note: I asked my friend Johnny Mac to do a story on the

“Black Sox.” Over the next three “chats,” he explores it in his

own inimitable way.]

With the World Series in the offing, we thought it was important

to revisit the most famous scandal in baseball history…the 1919

Chicago “Black Sox.” I”m sure even the most casual fan knows

the Cliff Notes version, namely that eight members of the team

conspired with gamblers to throw the World Series for money.

The eventual outcome is also well-known; that the players, the

infamous “Eight Men Out,” were banned from baseball for life.

There is so much more to the story though…what led up to the

fix, the state of baseball at the time, the personalities involved,

and how the scandal still affects baseball today. At its core it is a

simple tale, involving two commodities still in great abundance

today, greed and stupidity. You can find similar stories

throughout history, from politics to business to organized crime.

First, some background.

The White Sox of the late teens were a truly great team. They

had won the championship in 1917 and easily won the American

League pennant in 1919. It was a balanced club, featuring

excellent pitching, hitting and fielding. They had four quality

starters, Eddie Cicotte, Claude “Lefty” Williams, Urban “Red”

Faber and youngster Dickie Kerr. The line-up featured a bona

fide all-time great, “Shoeless” Joe Jackson, third baseman Buck

Weaver, who was on the precipice of greatness, Hall of Famer

Eddie Collins at second, and slick fielding Happy Felsch in

center. The supporting cast were solid major-leaguers, as well;

catcher Ray Schalk, first baseman Chick Gandil, and shortstop

Swede Risberg. They were managed by baseball “lifer” Kid

Gleason and owned by the legendary Charles Comiskey.

At a glance all would seem well, given the circumstance

described above. In reality, nothing could be farther from the

truth. The team was torn by dissension, broken up into basically

two factions. One, led by Gandil and Risberg, hated the

notoriously cheap Comiskey and resented the highly paid and

educated Collins. The other faction, including Collins, Schalk

and Kerr, were loyal to the ownership and viewed as “straight-

laced.” Players such as Jackson and Weaver, who had no

particular axe to grind, were nonetheless friendlier with the

Gandil crowd.

Comiskey”s frugality can not be overstated. He was an old-time

owner who reaped tremendous financial gain from his team

while treating his players like indentured servants. For those of

you too young to remember sports prior to free agency and

player”s unions, it was quite a different world. The reserve

clause, which bound a player to his team for life, was in full

effect. The courts had ruled in baseball”s favor regarding this,

basically exempting them from existing anti-trust laws. Players

who were offered contracts not to their liking could either sign

them or not play in the majors at all. There was no union, no

arbitration, and no recourse. Take it or leave it. In fact, most

contracts contained the dreaded (by the players) ten-day rule,

which allowed the ownership to fire a player with 10 days notice

for any reason (injury, incompetence, whatever) and not be

obligated to pay them the balance remaining on the contract. Not

a bad deal for the owners, huh? It was basically a risk-free

option on the player”s health and performance.

The system resembled the Middle Ages, with each team a

fiefdom, dependent on the largesse of its owner. There was no

real central authority to settle disputes, no commissioner or

governing body with any power. Common wisdom would

dictate that an owner who had come through the ranks as a

player, manager and front office director, as had Comiskey,

would be more sympathetic to the players plight. In fact,

Comiskey had bolted the National League for the upstart

American League, citing this treatment of players as his main

impetus. Funny how this works out in real life, however. A wise

man once told me to pick your enemies carefully because that”s

whom you eventually end up resembling.

That adage was all too applicable to Charles Comiskey. In an era

when owners could set the rules and treat players as they wished,

Comiskey stood out. In fact the common thought that the

nickname “Black Sox” referred to the scandal is wrong. The Sox

received that moniker because Comiskey charged the players 25

cents apiece to launder their uniforms, an uncommon practice

even in those times. The players balked at paying this fee,

choosing instead to play in dirty, unlaundered attire. This was

but one example. Comiskey also showered the press with gifts

and meals, hoping for good write-ups from the boys in the fourth

estate while giving his players the lowest per diem meal money

in the league. In another instance, as a reward for winning the

1917 Series, a case of flat champagne was sent to the locker

room (a cash reward had been promised, or at least hinted at).

And then there is the case of Eddie Cicotte, the dean of the staff,

who was promised a bonus for winning 30 games. Reaching 29

in early September, he was “rested” down the stretch. No bonus

was forthcoming.

This didn”t exactly foster good feelings between ownership and a

good majority of the players. As I mentioned previously, some

players were loyal soldiers, accustomed to the system, while

others, specifically Collins, were well paid. Collins was lucky

because Comiskey coveted his services and purchased him from

Connie Mack”s Philadelphia A”s. Part of the deal was that

Comiskey would assume Collins”s contract, a then robust $14,500

per year. Seeing as other top players on the Sox were making

about $6,000 per, you can imagine the erudite Mr. Collins (a

Columbia University grad) was not exactly well loved. This

contributed to the tension on the team.

Against this backdrop, the plot was hatched. First off, gambling

and baseball were not exactly strangers at this junction. You

don”t just fix a World Series as an isolated incident. One must

work up to that level. Gamblers regularly socialized with

players, plying them with drinks and meals. The object was

information. Who was hurt, who was going through a tough time

at home, who might have been hitting the bottle a little too much.

As any gambler can tell you, anything that gives you an edge is

valuable. The players, mostly underpaid and uneducated, saw

nothing (or chose to see nothing) wrong with this chummy little

arrangement…Monday, Part II.

Wildlife Follow-Up

Regarding my comments on skunks the other day, Harry K.

alerted me to the fact that if you are ever ”skunked,” tomato juice

doesn”t work. A mixture of hydrogen peroxide, water and

baking soda does the trick. [Harry has had lots of practice with

his dogs.]

Also, Harry alerted me to the story that Naoko Takahashi, the

women”s marathon winner in Sydney, credited drinking the

stomach juices of giant, killer hornets with her success. Yup, it”s

true. It seems that the hornets fly some 60 miles a day, at up to

20 mph, to get food for the young. Ergo, they have a lot of

stamina. And for Takahashi, it was all perfectly legal! As for

those of you who might be focusing on the word “stamina,”

you”re on your own. [Update: Takahashi”s nutrition supplement

is also mentioned in this week”s Sports Illustrated.]

Rick Jason

Hey, Lieutenant Gil Hanley from “Combat” died! Rick Jason.

He epitomized cool. But, unfortunately, he took his own life this

week. Last week, character actor Richard Farnsworth also

committed suicide. And it was just a week ago that Jason and

fellow “Combat” cast members attended a gathering for fans in

Las Vegas.

“Combat” was on ABC from 1962 to 1967, the longest-running

World War II series in television history. Of course, it also

starred Vic Morrow, who was killed in a helicopter crash in 1982

on the set of his film “Twilight Zone: The Movie.” [Man, time

flies.]

Jason did serve, himself, in the Army during WW II.

Top 3 songs for the week of 10/20/62: #1 “Monster Mash”

(Bobby “Boris” Pickett) #2 “Sherry” (The 4 Seasons) #3 “Do

You Love Me” (The Contours)

Spade Cooley

Harry K. also had to comment on my Bob Wills reference the

other day. It seems that Wills and Spade Cooley used to compete

in “Battle of the Bands” competitions, and Cooley”s orchestra

normally won. In fact, back in the 1940s, 75 percent of the

receivers in Los Angeles were tuned each Saturday night to “The

Hoffman Hayride” in which Cooley was the feature attraction.

But Cooley had a dark side. His drinking problem became worse

as the years went by and during the 1950s, his second marriage

disintegrated and he and his wife separated. But he couldn”t stop

seeing her and in July 1961, he killed her. [It was pretty

gruesome, actually. And it all came to a head because Cooley

thought his wife was sleeping with Roy Rogers…something that

wasn”t true.]

Cooley was convicted of murder in a sensational trial and

sentenced to life in prison. But, due to health problems, as well

as his good behavior, he was released from prison in 1970 for

just a few days to take part in a benefit concert in Oakland.

Spade played before a crowd of 3,000, which greeted him

warmly and, after thanking them “for the chance to be free for

awhile,” walked backstage where he slumped over, dead, of a

heart attack. [Source: “The Country Music Encyclopedia,” Irwin

Stambler and Grelun Landon.]

Geezuz, these last few articles were pretty ugly. Sorry about

that.

Steelers Quiz Answers: 1) Rushing, season – Barry Foster, 1690

(1992) 2) Passing, season – Terry Bradshaw, 3724 (1979) 3)

Receiving, career – John Stallworth, 537 4) Noll coached from

1969-1991. He was 1-13 in his first season, followed by 5-9 and

6-8 efforts, before he broke through with an 11-3 mark in 1972.

For his career, Noll was 193-148-1; 16-8 in the playoffs.

Mets / Yankees: A poll of New Yorkers finds that 47% support

the Yankees, 34% the Mets. The remaining 19% must still be

rooting for Brooklyn.

Mets in 6!!!…wrote the editor.

Next Bar Chat, Monday. More on the “Black Sox.”