Canada and WW II, Part Two

Canada and WW II, Part Two

Red Sox Quiz: 1) Name the managers who have guided them to

1st place finishes since 1967? 2) Who has the longest hitting

streak? 3) Most stolen bases, season? Answers below.

Canada and World War II…The Dieppe Raid

In the spring of 1942, a plan for what would become the largest

single raid of the war was hatched. Originally, up to 10,000 men

were to be employed against German positions along the French

coastline.

Codenamed RUTTER, the raid was planned by the British and

was to be under the command of Lt.-Gen. Montgomery. It was

ostensibly designed to be a morale-booster and probing action for

an eventual Second Front.

The original date for the operation was July 4 and the troops

embarked at ports in the Isle of Wight. But the weather proved

to be unfavorable and the date was changed to July 8. The foul

weather continued, however, so it was canceled on the 7th and

Gen. Montgomery recommended that it be postponed “for all

time” since the troops had been briefed and were now dispersed

ashore.

Winston Churchill, though, felt that some sort of large-scale

operation should take place that summer “and military opinion

seemed unanimous that until an operation on that scale was

undertaken no responsible general would take the responsibility of

planning for the main invasion (what would become D-Day).”

[Churchill]

So, British Vice-Admiral Mountbatten (who would be killed by

the IRA in 1979) revived the operation under the codename,

JUBILEE. Extraordinary security steps were taken in order to

ensure secrecy. No written records were kept.

Intensive photographic reconnaissance had revealed most of the

German defenses – though not the gun positions in the headland

cliffs that were to cause such slaughter – but intelligence was

lacking on other essentials. Little was known about the strength

of the positions or the whereabouts of the German command

posts.

Under pressure from Canadian authorities, who desired to see

their troops in action, the 2nd Canadian Division under the

command of Maj. Gen. J.H. Roberts was the main fighting force

(about 5,000, along with 1,000 British personnel and 50 U.S.

Rangers). At dawn on August 19, 1942 the attack was launched

along a ten-mile front.

Sent in without benefit of a softening-up bombardment, the main

body of the force landed directly at the fortified port of Dieppe

instead of on the open beaches nearby. Unreported machine gun

nests cut down the troops as they came ashore; one regiment lost

80 percent of its men. As the attack developed, it was directed

mainly against the heaviest defenses instead of flowing around the

flanks. About six hours after the raid was launched, withdrawal

commenced.

Of the 4,963 Canadians who had taken part, 3,367 were killed,

wounded, or taken prisoner, though 4,056 eventually survived.

British casualties amounted to 275. 33 landing craft were

destroyed and, equally disastrous, the RAF lost 106 aircraft, the

Luftwaffe just 48 of the 945 committed. German ground

casualties were only 591.

Churchill commented on the aftermath in his memoirs.

“Our postwar examination shows that the Germans did not

receive, through leakages of information, any special warning of

our intention to attack. However, their general estimate of the

threat to the Dieppe sector led to an intensification of defense

measures along the whole front. Special precautions were

ordered for periods like that between August 10 and August 19,

when moon and tide were favorable for landings…The Canadian

Army in Britain had long been eager and impatient for

action…and (while) many splendid deeds were done, the results

were disappointing and our casualties were very heavy.”

“Looking back, the casualties of this memorable action may seem

out of proportion to the results. It would be wrong to judge the

episode solely by such a standard. Dieppe occupies a place of its

own in the story of the war, and the grim casualty figures must

not class it as a failure. Tactically it was a mine of experience. It

shed revealing light on many shortcomings in our outlook. It

taught us to build in good time various new types of craft and

appliances for later us. Above all, it was shown that individual

skill and gallantry without thorough organization and combined

training would not prevail…Strategically, the raid served to

make the Germans more conscious of danger along the whole

coast of Occupied France. This helped to hold troops and

resources in the West, which did something to take the weight off

Russia. Honor to the brave who fell. Their sacrifice was not in

vain.”

That is Churchill”s take…and obviously, written for history. But

the same history shows that JUBILEE may not have been a

needed prelude to D-Day. It may have simply been an unjustified

gamble undertaken to please Sir Winston. [Your editor is a big

time fan of Churchill, but it needs to be acknowledged that

everyone makes mistakes and maybe this was one of them.]

[Sources: “The Oxford Companion to World War II.”

“Winston Churchill: Memoirs of the Second World War.”]

Fusaichi Pegasus

From sportswriter Ray Kerrison…”Unleashing one of the

greatest, smoothest, easiest finishing runs of modern times,

Fusaichi Pegasus simply devastated the 126th Kentucky Derby

to become the best Triple Crown prospect in years.”

“He is that, not because he won the Derby nicely, but because he

made a field of first-class horses look like Army mules.”

Top 3 songs for the week 5/4/74: #1 “The Loco-Motion” (Grand

Funk) #2 “TSOP (The Sound of Philadelphia)” (MFSB featuring

The Three Degrees) #3 “Bennie And The Jets” (Elton John)

Quiz Answers: 1) Winning Red Sox Managers – Dick Williams

”67, Darrell Johnson ”75, John McNamara ”86, McNamara / Joe

Morgan ”88, Joe Morgan ”90, Kevin Kennedy ”95.

2) Dom DiMaggio, 34 (1949) 3) Tommy Harper, 54 (1973).

Next Bar Chat, Wednesday…Underrated / Overrated. (Sorry for

the false alert last Friday)…and the final installment of songs that

peaked at #4.