Truman and the Bomb

Truman and the Bomb

Baltimore / Indianapolis Colts Quiz (1953-2000): 1) What year

did the franchise make the move to Indy? 2) Most pass

receptions, career? 3) Most rushing yards, career? 4) Most TD,

career? Answers below.

Harry Truman.In his own words

My friend Liz S. inquired as to how Harry Truman handled the

dropping of the first atomic bomb. Specifically, we were both

looking for his speech announcing it, which may provide a lesson

for the type of destruction that, someday, an American leader

may be forced to resort too as well.

Back in 1989, Truman”s daughter Margaret edited the musings of

President Truman, which he had written and dictated in the years

after he left office. He didn”t want his thoughts (which included

the “best” and “worst” presidents, in his opinion) to be released

until he died. Following are his comments on that fateful

decision to end World War II.

Truman: If I live to be a hundred years old, I”ll never forget the

day that I was first told about the atomic bomb. It was about

7:30 PM on the evening of April 12, 1945, just hours after

Franklin Roosevelt had died at 3:35 PM, and no more than half

an hour after I was sworn in as president at 7:09 PM. Henry L.

Stimson, who was Roosevelt”s secretary of war and then mine,

took me aside and reminded me that Roosevelt had authorized

the development of a sort of superbomb and that that bomb was

almost ready. I was still stunned by Roosevelt”s death and by the

fact that I was now president, and I didn”t think much more about

it at the time. But then, on April 26, Stimson asked for a meeting

in my office, at which he was joined by Major General Leslie

Groves, who was in charge of the operation that was developing

the bomb, the Manhattan Project. The meeting was so secret that

Groves came into the White House by the back door. And at the

meeting, Stimson handed me a memorandum that said, “Within

four months we shall in all probability have completed the most

terrible weapon ever known in human history, one bomb which

could destroy a whole city.”

Stimson said very gravely that he didn”t know whether we could

or should use the bomb because he was afraid that it was so

powerful that it could end up destroying the whole world. I felt

the same fear as he and Groves continued to talk about it, and

when I read Groves”s twenty-four-page report. The report said

that the first bomb would probably be ready by July and have the

strength of about five hundred tons of TNT, and even more

frighteningly, it went on to say that a second bomb would

probably be ready by August and have the strength of as much as

twelve hundred tons of TNT. We weren”t aware then that that

was just the tip of the iceberg. That second bomb turned out to

have the power of 20,000 tons of TNT, and the hydrogen bomb

that eventually followed it had the explosive power of twenty

million tons of TNT.

[Ed. A committee was then formed to advise the president on

whether or not to use the bomb on Japan. Members included

Enrico Fermi and J. Robert Oppenheimer, two of the lead

scientists on the project.]

Then, on May 8, my sixty-first birthday, the Germans

surrendered, and I had to remind our country that the war was

only half over, that we still had to face the war with Japan. The

winning of that war, we all knew, might even be more difficult to

accomplish, because the Japanese were self-proclaimed fanatic

warriors who made it all too clear that they preferred death to

defeat in battle (ed. like al Qaeda?) Just a month before, after

our soldiers and Marines landed on Okinawa, the Japanese lost

100,000 men out of the 120,000 in their garrison, and yet, though

they were defeated without any question in the world, thousands

more Japanese soldiers fell on their own grenades and died rather

than surrender.

Nevertheless, I pleaded with the Japanese in my speech

announcing Germany”s surrender, begging them to surrender,

too, but was not too surprised when they refused. And on June

18, I met with the Joint Chiefs of Staff to discuss what I hoped

would be our final push against the Japanese. We still hadn”t

decided whether or not to use the atomic bomb, and the chiefs of

staff suggested that we plan an attack on Kyushu, the Japanese

island on their extreme west, around the beginning of November,

and follow up with an attack on the more important island of

Honshu. But the statistics that the generals gave me were as

frightening as the news of the big bomb. The chiefs of staff

estimated that the Japanese still had five thousand attack planes,

seventeen garrisons on the island of Kyushu alone, and a total of

more than two million men on all of the islands of Japan.

General Marshall then estimated that, since the Japanese would

unquestionably fight even more fiercely than ever on their own

homeland, we would probably lose a quarter of a million men

and possibly as many as a half million in taking the two islands.

I could not bear this thought, and it led to the decision to use the

atomic bomb.

We talked first about blockading Japan and trying to blast them

into surrender with conventional weaponry; but Marshall and

others made it clear that this would never work, pointing out that

we”d hit Germany in this way and they hadn”t surrendered until

we got troops into Germany itself. Another general also pointed

out that Germany”s munitions industries were more or less

centralized and that our constant bombings of these facilities

never made them quit, and Japan”s industries were much more

spread apart and harder to hit. Then, when we finally talked

about the atomic bomb, on July 21, coming to the awful

conclusion that it would probably be the only way the Japanese

might be made to surrender quickly, we talked first about hitting

some isolated area, some low-population area where there would

not be too many casualties but where the Japanese could see the

power of the new weapon. Reluctantly, we decided against that

as well, feeling that that just wouldn”t be enough to convince the

fanatic Japanese. And we finally selected four possible target

areas, all heavy military-manufacturing areas (ed. Including

Hiroshima and Nagasaki).

I know the world will never forget that the first bomb was

dropped on Hiroshima on August 5, at 7:15 PM Washington time

(Aug. 6 in Japan), and the second on Nagasaki on August 9. One

more plea for surrender had been made to the Japanese on July

29, and was rejected immediately. Then I gave the final order,

saying I had no qualms “if millions of lives could be saved.” I

meant both American and Japanese lives.

The Japanese surrendered five days after the bomb was dropped

on Nagasaki, and a number of major Japanese military men and

diplomats later confirmed publicly that there would have been no

quick surrender without it. For this reason, I made what I

believed to be the only possible decision. I said something to

this effect in a letter to my sister, Mary: “It was a terrible

decision. But I made it. And I made it to save 250,000 boys

from the United States, and I”d make it again under similar

circumstances.”

[In a 1965 speech Truman added the following:]

It was a question of saving hundreds of thousands of American

lives.You don”t feel normal when you have to plan hundreds of

thousands of.deaths of American boys who are alive and joking

and having fun while you”re doing your planning. You break

your heart and your head trying to figure out a way to save one

life.The name given to our invasion plan was Olympic, but I

saw nothing godly about the killing of all the people that would

be necessary to make that invasion. The casualty estimates

called for 750,000 American casualties – 250,000 killed, 500,000

maimed for life.I couldn”t worry about what history would say

about my personal morality. I made the only decision I ever

knew how to make. I did what I thought was right.

[Following are excerpts from President Truman”s statement to

the American people on August 6, 1945…after the first bomb

was dropped.]

.We are now prepared to obliterate more rapidly and

completely every productive enterprise the Japanese have above

ground in any city. We shall destroy their docks, their factories,

and their communications. Let there be no mistake; we shall

completely destroy Japan”s power to make war.

It was to spare the Japanese people from utter destruction that the

ultimatum of July 26 was issued at Potsdam. Their leaders

promptly rejected that ultimatum. If they do not now accept our

terms they may expect a rain of ruin from the air, the like of

which has never been seen on this earth. Behind this air attack

will follow sea and land forces in such numbers and power as

they have not yet seen and with the fighting skill of which they

are already well aware.

[Source: “Where the Buck Stops: The Personal and Private

Writings of Harry S. Truman,” edited by Margaret Truman.

Note: It has never been my habit to quote so extensively from a

book like this but this is all in the public record and it”s our

history, which I feel a certain duty to share where appropriate.]

Top 3 songs for the week of 10/23/65: #1 “Yesterday” (The

Beatles) #2 “Treat Her Right” (Roy Head) #3 “A Lover”s

Concerto” (The Toys)

*Harry K. reminds me that a “Top 3″ group from last week, ”?

(Mark) & The Mysterians,” originally was formed in Flint, MI in

1962 and took their quirky name from the obscure science fiction

movie “The Mysterians.” Their only hit, “96 Tears” was one of

the great garage band classics of the 60s. Lead singer Question

Mark had two real names, Rudy Martinez and Reeto Rodriguez.

But the drummer, Mel Schacher, was a founding member of

Grand Funk Railroad. And now you know…the rest of the story.

College Football

Congratulations to Nebraska for toppling Oklahoma on Saturday.

But with all of the upsets this weekend, and with Nebraska

having to probably face Oklahoma again in December, who

knows how the BCS will play out? What we do know is that

Fresno State”s 15 minutes of fame is long over. Thank goodness

I didn”t waste money acquiring a Fresno State t-shirt as a way of

hopping on the bandwagon. [I did, incidentally, purchase about

10 Black Hills State t-shirts on my recent trip to Spearfish, SD.

I”m now convinced that after watching Fresno State lose to Boise

State and Hawaii on consecutive weekends, Black Hills State

would give them a tussle.] And Joe Paterno deserves a little

credit for whipping two decent clubs the past two weekends in

finally besting Bear Bryant”s all-time college mark of 323 wins.

Wild Bear Alert

The New Jersey black bear population now stands at 1,400.

Crocodiles

There is a rather detailed report on saltwater crocodiles in the

current issue of Smithsonian magazine, reported by Derek

Grzelewski (to give him his due). What I learned is that there are

thousands of these dinosaurs in Australia, with the record being

one that was hunted down in 1957, 28” 4″! Since 1876, there

have been 60 confirmed croc attacks Down Under, with 27

fatalities, but experts say there are far more that have gone

unreported. However, Nile crocodiles kill 300-400 a year! One

other tidbit, crocs just love dogs. “Their barking is like the jingle

of an ice-cream truck to a child.”

Middle Linebackers

Sports Illustrated”s long-time football writer Paul Zimmerman

listed his Top Ten middle linebackers in NFL history.

1. Dick Butkus

2. Ray Lewis

3. Joe Schmidt

4. Willie Lanier

5. Ray Nitschke

6. Jack Lambert

7. Mike Singletary

8. Lee Roy Jordan

9. Sam Mills

10. Bill Bergey

I like where Lanier is ranked, but I”m partial to Jack Lambert and

would place him 3rd. Sam Mills?! C”mon. Quality player, yes;

Top Ten, no.

Colts Quiz Answers: 1) Franchise moved from Baltimore to

Indy in 1984. 2) Receptions, career: Raymond Berry, 631.

Berry fumbled only once in his career! 3) Rushing, career:

Lydell Mitchell, 5,487 yards (he also played for San Diego and

the L.A. Rams.ending up with 6,534 as well as 376 receptions,

leading the league twice in the latter category). 4) TD, career:

Lenny Moore, 113. Moore, like Mitchell, was a Penn State grad

and had an incredible career. Operating out of the HB – FL slot,

3 seasons he averaged over 7 yards a carry.”56: 86-649, 7.5;

”58: 82-598, 7.3; ”61: 92-648, 7.0. On the receiving end, from

1958-60 Moore averaged between 18 and 21 yards a reception in

catching 45 to 50 balls each of those years. So quaff an ale to

Hall of Famer Lenny Moore. [Berry is also in the Hall, Mitchell

is not.]

Next Wednesday, a story or two involving musical groups from

the British Invasion.