Heavy Stuff and Stability Islands

Heavy Stuff and Stability Islands

Temptation Island is apparently a TV show designed to foster

instability and disorder in a world that seems to me to have quite

enough of both already. On the other hand, the Periodic Table,

with its neat and orderly rows and columns of the elements, is a

bedrock of chemistry. When it was proposed by the Russian

Dmitri Mendeleyev in the mid 1800s, there were only 60 known

chemical elements. Each element has an atomic number, which

is simply the number of electrons orbiting the nucleus. Element

number 1 is hydrogen, with just one electron. Uranium, with its

92 electrons, is number 92. Mendeleyev left empty spaces in his

table and, sure enough, these empty spots were filled in later as

the missing elements were discovered.

If you”re a nuclear physicist, you might prefer to call the atomic

number the number of protons in the nucleus. That”s ok since the

protons are positively charged and the number of protons in the

nucleus equals the number of electrons outside the nucleus. That

way everything is neatly balanced. The nucleus also contains

neutrons, which have no charge. This is important because it

allows a chemical element to exist in several different forms

known as “isotopes”.

The simplest example again is hydrogen. You have ordinary

hydrogen composed of just one proton and one electron. You

also have the hydrogen found in so-called “heavy” water. This

isotope of hydrogen has a proton and a neutron in its nucleus and

is also known as deuterium. Since the proton and neutron weigh

about the same, deuterium is twice as heavy as ordinary

hydrogen. It still only has one electron and acts chemically like

ordinary hydrogen. For completeness, there is a third form of

hydrogen, known as tritium, which has two neutrons and a

proton in the nucleus but still only one electron. (We can forget

here about the quarks and gluons and stuff that make up protons

and neutrons. They just complicate things unnecessarily.)

When I was in high school, there were only 92 elements, the

heaviest one being uranium. By the time I graduated from

college, there were two more and the whole world knew about

element number 94, plutonium. That was the critical ingredient

in “Fat Man”, the atomic bomb dropped on Nagasaki. I”ve been

to the museum at Sandia in New Mexico and seeing the replicas

of Fat Man and Little Boy, the bomb dropped on Hiroshima, is a

sobering experience.

The discovery of plutonium and neptunium, element number 93,

was the beginning of a concerted effort to create other new, even

heavier elements. The effort has been quite successful. I just

checked the Periodic Table in my Encarta 97 CD encyclopedia

and found that the heaviest element listed was number 111.

What prompted this column, however, was an article by Sonja

Bisbee Wulff in the American Chemical Society publication

Chemistry, Autumn 2000 issue, which perhaps should have been

described as Winter 2001 since it just arrived in the mail. At any

rate, what excited me was that the heaviest element is now

number 118, seven more than in my Encarta 97.

You probably are thinking, “What”s the big deal?” The big deal

is not just that more elements have been created but there”s an

island involved. This island may not have the scintillating

qualities of “Temptation Island”, which I haven”t seen and don”t

plan to. Quite the opposite of Temptation, with what I gather is

its attempts to inject instability into committed relationships, the

island I”m talking about could better be called “Stability Island”.

It is this island of stability for which heavy element researchers

have been striving for decades.

Let”s set the stage by considering the property of radioactive

elements known as the half-life. Who said anything about

radioactivity and why worry about half-life? Well, have you

ever tried pushing two magnets together with the north poles of

each facing each other? Similarly, protons, with their positive

charges tend to repel each other. Maybe I”ll renege on my

statement to forget quarks and gluons for a moment and just

mention that we”ve discussed in an earlier column why the

nucleus doesn”t just fly apart. However, as you put more and

more protons together, as in uranium, the protons really want to

push away from each other and the nucleus become unstable. It

splits up, ejects various particles and turns into some other

element or elements, i.e., we have radioactivity. The half-life is

the time for half of a given sample of the element to decay. If

you have a pound of plutonium, 82 million years later you only

have half a pound left. The half-life is 82 million years and is a

huge problem for our future descendants. Disposing of nuclear

waste, particularly plutonium and other elements with long half-

lives, has to be done in such a way that succeeding generations

will know and be able to deal with the nuclear waste disposal

sites.

The reason for bringing up the half-life concept is that the half-

lives of the elements heavier than plutonium have generally been

zillions of times smaller than the half-life of plutonium. Half-

lives of a second or small fractions of a second are the rule. But

theorists have predicted that if one could make elements that

were superheavy enough, there could be an “island of stability”

for which the half-lives would be much longer.

Enter the Russians. The economic situation in Russia is

disastrous but they still manage some first rate science. Two

years ago, in January 1999, at the Joint Institute for Nuclear

Research near Moscow, they bombarded plutonium with calcium

and claimed to have made the heaviest element to date, number

114. Number 114 have 114 protons and 175 neutrons. But the

real joy was to be found when they measured the half-life. It was

30 seconds! You are no doubt thinking that”s nothing to cheer

about. However, to a nuclear physicist who”s had to deal with

half-lives of tiny fractions of a second, 30 seconds is like an

eternity. They”ve reached an island of stability.

The reason I noted that the Russian element 114 had 175

neutrons is that the theorists predict that element 114 should be a

so-called “doubly magic” element. Their calculations indicate

that if you could cram not 175, but 184 neutrons into element

114 you would have an isotope that should be at the peak of

Stability Island. No predictions are given for the value of the

half-life of this magic element and speculations that it might be

so stable that someday new materials might be made of 114 are

probably overly optimistic. Nevertheless, you can bet that there”s

going to be a lot of effort to ram in those neutrons and if half-

lives of months or years are obtained, the researchers will be

ecstatic!

The Russian work was performed in collaboration with the

Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California. Within

6 months of the 114 achievement, workers at Lawrence Berkeley

National Laboratory, also in California, had jumped over 114 to

form element 118, which promptly decayed to form another new

guy, number 116. They did it by bombarding lead with krypton.

To give you some idea of the difficulty involved in these types of

experiments, the Berkeley group took 11 days of experimenting

to find only 3 atoms of 118, which quickly tossed out a helium

nucleus to become 116. Three atoms ain”t many! It”s a tribute to

the wizardry of these nuclear guys and gals who can detect and

measure the properties of these few fleeting atoms.

The Berkeley group uses a cyclotron to make these new

elements. This atom smasher allows particles to whiz around a

doughnut shaped apparatus and periodically get goosed to higher

and higher energies. When these particles smash into the target

element, the energies are so high that the repulsion of all those

protons is overcome and a new nucleus is formed. This nucleus

is normally unstable and decays to another unstable element, as

with 118 going to 116.

It seems only fitting that one of the superheavy elements now

bears the name of mendelevium. When Mendeleyev constructed

his Periodic Table, he could not have anticipated it would grow

to almost twice as many elements as the 60 that were known to

exist at the time. I just went on the Web to try to determine if I

should have said twice and not “almost twice”. I didn”t find any

more elements after 118. I did find out what happens when 118

goes to 116, however. Element 116 quickly goes to our “stable”

30-second 114. I knew you were dying to find out!

Those Russians aren”t stuck on superheavy stuff. They also are

fiddling with the superlight, namely hydrogen. Remember that I

said there are three forms or isotopes of hydrogen? Well, I

hadn”t read the Chemistry article thoroughly enough. It seems

that last year the Russians managed to goose a couple more

neutrons into the hydrogen nucleus, making it 4 neutrons and 1

proton. I don”t know what they call it but I suspect we now have

quintium! Who knows what comes next?

Allen F. Bortrum