Twisted Minds and Mirrors

Twisted Minds and Mirrors

This morning I made a special effort to be on the beach shortly

after 6 AM and was beautifully rewarded. Those who have read

my earlier years” columns from Marco Island may guess

correctly that this was one of those mornings when the full moon

sets as the first rays of dawn appear in the opposite direction.

The moon was behind some clouds when I started walking but

emerged fully as a bright orange orb just before setting. Turning

around a bank of mackerel clouds was painted a brilliant pink by

the about-to-emerge sun – spectacular! I also walked a mile or

two beyond where I had walked in previous years. It was a

different world, with no hotels and only a couple of intrepid shell

seekers to be seen.

A distressing aspect of my walk was the huge number of dead

fish, casualties of the red tide. I hadn”t planned to mention any

more about the tide, but I have made some observations that

intrigued me over the past weeks. When the red tide first

appeared, the dead fish were all the same type and virtually the

same size, foot-long mullets. A day or two later, it seemed as

though a school of much smaller fish were affected. The newly

deceased were uniformly 2-3 inches long and reminded me of

sardines. In another day or so, a raft of intermediate size fish,

about 6 inches long, appeared. It was as though the Gulf was

running them through sieves of different size openings.

Then we had a daylong rainstorm with very high winds and the

next day, all bets were off. The beach was littered with all

shapes and sizes of marine life. There were flat fish, big fish (3

feet long), foot-wide skates, hermit crabs and other crab

varieties, starfish, sand dollars and all kinds of shells and

shellfish. I had never seen what I assume was a recently living

shrimp on Marco Island”s beach before. I had a golden

opportunity to collect a very large shell that would have been $20

in the shell store. Unfortunately, the shell was still inhabited by

its owner, a creature that looked to me like a bright red pound of

liver. Not only would I have been ignorant of the procedure for

cleaning out the shell but also taking live shells off the beach is

illegal. According to one of the local Marco publications that I

read just a few minutes ago, the reason for the law again

harvesting “live” shells is that these live shells provide food for

the shore birds. The law is very effective – I”ve walked through

groups of hundreds of gulls and other birds on the beach.

Perhaps it”s the full moon and/or the red tide that causes some

people”s minds to get a bit twisted or warped down here in

Florida. Take an item in Sunday”s Naples Daily News. There

was this guy hitting a fellow on the head with a beer bottle.

Nothing unusual about that – happens all the time, doesn”t it?

But you”ll have to admit it isn”t every day that a fellow responds

by stabbing the guy with a swordfish!

If both of those fellows” minds were a bit twisted, mine was also

out of sync on Sunday. Not only did I forget to take the key to

our condo when I left on my predawn walk, but after making my

customary orange juice-banana drink in the blender and cleaning

the blender, I realized I forgot to add the banana. The banana-

orange juice blend not only supplies extra potassium to counter

the diuretic blood pressure pill but also helps the morning

vitamins and pills go down smoothly. After drinking the glass of

blend and taking my pills, I notice a green thing on the floor. For

the first time in my life, my blood pressure pill had not

completed its journey from container to my mouth! Hopefully,

all these things were due to the moon or red tide and not to some

serious mental problem.

In addition to twisted minds, there are twisted mirrors, which

serve the noble objective of exploring our universe. What

brought this to mind was an article by Marcia Dunn, also in

Sunday”s Naples Daily News, concerning the launch this week of

the space shuttle Columbia. Columbia”s mission is a major

servicing of the Hubble Space Telescope that includes

replacement of the power control unit and damaged solar panels,

repair of one camera and installation of a new one, etc. It”s an

awesome job that NASA has assigned these astronauts, one of

them a veterinarian skilled in performing surgery on elephants,

whales, rhinoceroses and other animals. Who would have

thought that such a background qualifies one to do surgery on an

orbiting space telescope?

With the new and rejuvenated equipment, it is hoped that Hubble

will bring back photos and data on wider areas of the sky and

maybe gather information on when the first galaxies formed and

uncover more planets orbiting nearby stars. The Hubble has cost

many billions of dollars over the years to maintain and operate

but it has amply repaid us with over 400,000 exposures of

thousands of different areas of the universe. To date, over 3,200

papers have been published utilizing data from the Hubble.

The Hubble has been so successful primarily due to the fact that

out in space it can operate free from the atmospheric distortions

that limit the performance of earthbound telescopes. These

distortions are what cause stars to twinkle and that twinkling

causes fuzzy pictures of distant objects taken by telescopes on

earth. Without the distortions, Hubble gives much sharper

images.

What does all this have to do with twisted mirrors? “Adaptive

optics” is the answer. I”ve touched on this briefly over a year

ago, though not by this name as I recall. An article by Bob

Berman in the March 2002 issue of Discover is titled “Twisted

Mirrors Sharpen the View” and is one of several articles I”ve

read on the subject of adaptive optics. First, what is the twinkle

of a star due to? As light from a star travels through the

atmosphere it bends as it passes through different layers of the

atmosphere with different temperatures and, I would guess,

compositions. As temperatures change, the bending is different

so, over a period of time required for the telescope to gather

enough light for an image, the light comes from different

directions and the image is fuzzy.

Let”s take one example of adaptive optics cited by Berman. It

involves a “synthetic star”. The “star” is a patch of sodium

atoms out in the upper atmosphere somewhere. (I”m assuming

these sodium atoms were placed there by some rocket shot of

some sort.) Now let”s shoot a laser beam up at the sodium “star”.

Sodium when excited gives off a yellow light. By measuring the

twinkle of this synthetic star, if we”re clever we can then

translate the twinkle into a correction to apply to our telescope,

which is looking at a real star or galaxy.

How do we do this? Let”s take the image we get from our

telescope and send it to a flexible mirror. Now connect the

mirror to a few hundred tiny pistons controlled by our computer.

By activating these little pistons, or actuators, we can push and

pull and twist the various sections of the mirror to compensate

for the twinkle. We can do this hundreds of times a second. The

results are astounding. The Discover article shows pictures of

the planet Neptune taken by the Keck telescope on Mauna Kea in

Hawaii. The normal picture shows a blurry blob with a

suggestion of a dark area and a pronounced round bright spot.

With adaptive optics, Neptune emerges with clearly defined

bands of cloud formations and the bright spot is resolved onto

two bright areas, neither of which is remotely round. (I should

note that I”m not sure that the synthetic star method was used

with the Keck photos; there are other techniques.)

As a result of adaptive optics, ground based telescopes will

compete with the Hubble to see which will be the first to deliver

an actual image of a planet outside our solar system. Some feel

that day may come within the next year or so. There are some

limitations, however. For the larger telescopes, adaptive optics

so far is only feasible for infrared light, which isn”t as affected by

atmospheric distortions. It seems those pistons can”t twist those

flexible mirrors fast enough to keep up with the twinkling of

visible light in telescopes bigger than 15 feet. I guess you never

can have everything.

Lest you think adaptive optics is only useful for astronomical

purposes, spy satellites use it to resolve smaller features –

possibly less than a foot in size. There are camcorders and

binoculars on the market that use different adaptive optics

methods to provide jitter-free images.

Returning to twisted minds, in case you”re wondering, both the

guy with the beer bottle and the fellow with the swordfish were

charged with aggravated battery. The swordfish stabber

required stitches for his head injuries while the beer bottle basher

was in fair condition, with wounds to his lower abdomen. As for

me, since last Sunday I”ve remembered my key, added the

bananas and swallowed my pills on the first try!

Allen F. Bortrum